
Infectious
diarrhea from all causes is a major cause of morbidity and mortality
among international travelers, including those who frequent wilderness
areas. It would be wonderful if there was a vaccine against one or more
of the infectious agents, which are commonly viruses, bacteria, and
protozoa. Approximately a year ago, there was a publication in the
journal Lancet (2008 Jun 14;371[9629]:2019-25) entitled "Use of a patch
containing heat-labile toxin from
Escherichia coli
against travellers' diarrhoea: a phase II, randomised, double-blind,
placebo-controlled field trial" by SA Frech and colleagues.
To summarize what was published, it was noted that enterotoxigenic
E. coli
(ETEC) is a significant cause of diarrhea. These investigators were
interested in evaluating the safety and efficacy of a
vaccine-containing skin patch that delivered a heat-labile (e.g.,
sensitive to heat) toxin from ETEC.
To look at the issue,
healthy adults aged 18-64 years were chosen who planned to travel to
Mexico or Guatemala. They were vaccinated, utilizing patches, prior to
travel. The method was to place two patches 2 to 3 weeks apart. The
patches either contained the heat-labile toxin or placebo. The study
individuals keep a "diarrhea diary and if they were stricken, yielded a
sample to the laboratory for examination to attempt to determine the
precise cause of the diarrhea.
When diarrhea struck, it was
graded by the number of loose stools in 24 hours: mild diarrea (three
stools), moderate (four to five), and severe (at least six). Of the
approximately 200 enrollees who were given patches, 178 received two
vaccinations and traveled. Twenty-four (22%) of 111 placebo recipients
had diarrhea, of whom 11 (10%) had ETEC diarrhea.
The results
were encouraging. The vaccine was safe and provoked an immune response.
The patch recipients were protected against moderate-to-severe diarrhea
and severe diarrhea. Patch recipients who became ill had shorter
episodes of diarrhea with fewer loose stools than did patients with
diarrhea who had received only placebo.
There is much about
this study to provoke encouragement. First, it appears that the antigen
used in the vaccine is effective. Second, administering a vaccine by
patch eliminates the needle stick(s) associated with most other
immunizations. Given the enormous distribution of patients with
diarrhea, it would be marvelous to be able to apply immunization
techniques to diminish the disease burden.
Future studies will
no doubt look to refine the dose, define extenuating circumstances
where this immunization would not be expected to work, and extend the
development process to attempt to mitigate other germs, such as
Campylobacter, norovirus, and perhaps even
Giardia lamblia. If we could create a "multivalent" vaccine, that would be most useful.
Preview the Annual Meeting of the Wilderness Medical Society, which will be held in Snowmass, Colorado July 24-29, 2009.Join me from January 24 to February 2, 2010 for
an exciting dive and wilderness medicine CME adventure aboard the Nautilus Explorer to Socorro Island, Mexico to benefit the
Wilderness Medical Society.